How can there be tension when the viewer’s assured the character will always succeed? And what’s the viewer’s reason for liking or caring about the character at all?Ĭonsider The Martian, a movie in which Matt Damon’s botanist astronaut Mark Watney is basically a near-future Sherlock stranded on another planet. He is the only one who can save us." Stories that come to revolve around extremely smart, equally arrogant people all struggle to answer the same basic questions. "Sherlock Holmes is the smartest and best. They’re the ones who figure out the puzzle every time," VanDerWerff writes. " protagonists have a tendency to become strange, alien gods after a few seasons. In a critical review of The Abominable Bride, Vox’s Todd VanDerWerff made a smart point about the narrative problem Sherlock’s astounding cleverness poses. Again, this feels more like bait for Tumblr fans than the seeds of a lasting change.) Of course, the culmination of the show’s interaction with the movement is a speech in which Sherlock bemoans the injustice of the whole thing while a room of women stands silent around him. (To hear Hudson tell it, she’s good for more than serving tea and worrying, though you wouldn’t know it from the show’s first three seasons.
Hudson (Una Stubbs) complements the show’s lite-feminist inclinations. The circumstances and particulars of the case allow Moffat and Gatiss to push Sherlock into England’s suffragette movement, and fourth-wall-sniffing commentary from Watson’s wife Mary (Amanda Abbington) and Baker Street landlady Mrs. The present-day Sherlock is an anti-hero, sure the dream Victorian Sherlock is just obnoxious. Everyone around Sherlock is an idiot, helpless and blithering in the face of his intellect his brother Mycroft (Gatiss, pulling his customary double duty), typically the only check on his roaring brain, is obese to the point of immobility and killing himself to prove a point. We’re on to season four.īecause Sherlock is the author of the fantasy that gives the episode his shape, we see every character and plot turn through Sherlock’s eyes, and the result is a warped world that’s more frustrating in its unlikelihood than usual. When all's said and done, a grand total of 10 "real" minutes have passed. Once it’s been established that we’ve entered the province of Sherlock’s mind, anything can happen, and this rule ends up being extremely convenient from a fan service perspective. I’m not ruining the plot by telling you this Inception-esque scenario ends with Sherlock and Moriarty wrestling soaked under the Reichenbach Falls, a fight after which Sherlock flies high (in the friendly sky) like a true comic book superhero. Present-day Sherlock is an anti-hero Victorian Sherlock is just obnoxious It’s heightening an elaborate fantasy within his "mind palace," and it revolves around an old case that he’s using to solve the mystery of his nemesis Moriarty’s (Andrew Scott) apparent return. This isn’t a true alternate reality, though: having had his season-ending suicidal mission cancelled, the present-day Sherlock has taken a potent - and potentially lethal - drug cocktail.
The pair’s newest case involves a suicidal bride, one who’s somehow come back from the dead to enact vengeance on London’s deadbeat husband and lovers. Sherlock solves mysteries alongside the befuddled detectives of Scotland Yard Watson writes about their adventures in The Strand. It turns out Sherlock (Benedict Cumberbatch) and Watson’s (Martin Freeman) 19th century life and work aren’t much different from their 21st century incarnations. There are spoilers for both The Abominable Bride and the first three seasons of Sherlock beyond this point. (It takes a long time to get in and out of that Doctor Strange costume.) It would be unfortunate for any show to go three years without so much as a morsel of story, but that would almost be preferable to The Abominable Bride, whose commitment to producing new Sherlock content at all costs renders it knotty, obtuse, and strangely paced. The boldness is commendable, and it’s probably necessary: Sherlock’s fourth season won’t air until 2017, a consequence of its stars’ packed schedules. This is a quasi-holiday special, sure, but it’s also a complicated interstitial piece of Sherlock’s overall narrative and a vehicle for entry-level social commentary, winking meta-criticism, and fanfic-spawning setpieces. Of course, creators Steven Moffat and Mark Gatiss are a little more ambitious. Combine the promotional focus, the Christmas setting, and the seemingly lightweight premise - a vengeful bride has risen from the dead! - and you have a recipe for repeated late-December viewing. Everything released in advance of its January 1st premiere focused mostly on Victorian London’s dashing menswear and Martin Freeman’s robust mustache. If you went into this year’s Sherlock holiday special The Abominable Bride expecting a period-piece trifle, no one can blame you.
0 kommentar(er)
